In the aftermath of the US midterm elections, Vice President JD Vance attributed the results to the ongoing Iran war, pointing to affordability as the decisive issue for voters. He argued that foreign policy decisions, such as the conflict with Iran, had driven up fuel prices and inflation. Pre-election polling supported this view, with nearly two-thirds of Americans disapproving of President Donald Trump's foreign policy.
But do the experts who shape and critique US foreign policy share these concerns? To find out, the University of Texas at Austin, in partnership with the Chicago Council on Global Affairs, surveyed 449 US foreign policy leaders from the executive branch, Congress, think tanks, interest groups, media, and academia. Their answers matter because these experts will be tasked with finding solutions to the Iran war and the fallout of tariff policies, and they are likely to advise presidential candidates ahead of the 2028 elections.
Areas of consensus and disagreement
On some issues, there is striking bipartisan agreement. The survey found strong consensus on the need for the US to play an active role in the world, support for NATO, and the willingness to use force to defend European allies if attacked. Ninety-three percent of experts want the US to take an active part globally, including 83% of Republicans, 98% of Democrats, and 90% of independents.
More than 70% of Democrats and over 80% of Republicans and independents agree that military power has been very important to American influence. Over 90% of all partisan groups say economic power has been very important. However, these points of agreement mask deep divisions on specific policies.
On the Iran war, 98% of Democrats and 73% of independent experts say the war was the wrong decision, while 58% of Republican leaders say it was correct. On tariffs, all Democrats and 81% of independents say they are bad for the US economy, while 53% of Republicans say they are good.
America First and the turn to coercion
The Trump administration has challenged the foundations of US foreign policy through its America First agenda, prioritizing domestic and economic interests over international agreements and alliances. The administration has used tariffs, threats, and military force—including against traditional allies—to achieve its ends. Tariffs have been applied not only to rivals like China but also to allies in Europe and Asia. The administration has also expressed interest in territorial expansion, such as acquiring Greenland or even Canada as a 51st state.
Beyond the Iran war and operations against the Venezuelan president, the administration has struck boats in the Caribbean suspected of drug trafficking. This coercive approach raises questions about the sustainability of US power.
The downsides of coercion
The survey asked experts whether it is more important for the US to be feared or admired. Sixty-two percent of Republican leaders said it is more important to be feared, while 97% of Democrats and 81% of independents said it is more important to be admired.
When asked whether other countries have options to oppose US coercion, 39% of Republican experts agreed that “Other countries largely have to accept what the U.S. dictates,” while no Democrats and only 11% of independents agreed. A majority of Democrats (55%) and independents (54%) chose the option that “Other countries will accept what the US dictates in the short run but will distance themselves from United States order in the longer run.” Notably, 48% of Republicans also agreed with this view, suggesting some recognition that coercive power has limits.
Furthermore, 44% of Democrats and 35% of independents said that “Other countries have viable options in the short and long run to resist US coercion,” compared to only 13% of Republicans.
These partisan gaps reveal fundamental disagreements about the foundations of US power. As the US navigates the Iran war and tariff disputes, the next president may need to engage in more vigorous dialogue with allies and adversaries alike. The findings also resonate in the Indo-Pacific, where US coercion has strained relations with allies like South Korea and Japan, as seen in the hollowing out of US-Korea alliance expertise and Trump's brief Manila stop. The region watches closely as Washington debates its global role.


